Edmund Burke & His Views on Representative Government
Edmund Burke & His Views on Representative Government
Free Online Articles Directory
Why Submit Articles?
Top Authors
Top Articles
FAQ
AB Answers
0 && $.browser.msie ) {
var ie_version = parseInt($.browser.version);
if(ie_version Hello Guest
Login
Register
Hello
My Home
Sign Out
Email
Password
Remember me?
Lost Password?
Home Page > Education > Edmund Burke & His Views on Representative Government
Edmund Burke & His Views on Representative Government
Posted: Aug 26, 2010 |Comments: 0
|
]]>
Edmund Burke & His Views on Representative Government
By: Nicolas DAlleva
About the Author
This article has been provided by Specialty Answering Service. Specialty is available as an Minnesota answering service and Colorado answering service provider. We answer for each client 24 hours a day and follow their instructions to handle each inbound or outbound communication perfectly.
(ArticlesBase SC #3137294)
Article Source: http://www.articlesbase.com/ – Edmund Burke & His Views on Representative Government
The notion of the value of popular opinion in government has long remained one of the most hotly debated issues of public representation since the inception of representative government. Though the representatives in a governmental body are undoubtedly there to serve the people they govern, the question remains whether they serve their people better by voting in the pursuit of the common good or rather they vote toward the opinions of their immediate constituents. Edmund Burke argues in favor of a representative government that serves its people through the pursuit of the common good rather their constituent opinions, and furthermore, argues that the latter philosophy on representative government is not only harmful to the effectiveness of a the government as a whole, but is destructive to the entire governmental system. In his Speech to the Electors of Bristol, Burke claims that the representatives in a government maintain the distinct responsibility to serve the government and the country, and not be swayed by the whims of the people that elected them but rather serve them through service to the country as a whole. This idea stands in direct contrast to the concept of populism, and downright debunks this ideology to an extent. Burke is correct in his claim that a representative does hold the responsibility to serve his or her country rather than just a small group of interests, however, in a practical sense, this form of representative government often alienates the people’s interests entirely. The national interest is a very vague concept however, and is more readily defined by the majority opinion, rather than through contrary foresight. Burke’s argument practically falls apart if one defines the national interest as a concept determined by the people as a whole. The current system of government in the United States has undoubtedly deviated from Burke’s original opinions, centering much more on the opinions of the people rather than the judgment of the elected officials themselves. This has surely limited the freedom of the representatives and forever chained them to their electorate. Through an analysis of Burke’s ideologies, it becomes incredibly clear the intention of representative democracy as a whole and the original intent of the United States governmental system.
Edmund Burke argues that the representatives elected to a government have the responsibility to vote according to their own judgments in the pursuit of the common good, rather than the judgments of the people that elected them. This is surely the ideal manner in which the government should conduct itself. It stands to sound reason that the government should be impartial in all decisions regarding things that would be good for the country as a whole, or the national interest. However, having said this, it is also undeniable that this form of government can easily lead to the alienation of the people as whole, rather than the alienation of public opinion. It is true that public opinion is incredible volatile in determining policies that would benefit the country, the absence of the people from the government could lead to an incredible disaster. The government must be familiar with the desires of the people in order to maintain an accurate definition of what the national interest is. Numbers and facts often do not tell the entire story on the state of the nation as a whole. When the people are eliminated completely from the decision making process of government, the government itself ceases to become a representative body of legislature, and rather becomes a governing body completely out of touch and unfamiliar with the people it controls. If the government is unfamiliar with the people it governs entirely, it cannot effectively serve those people in any kind of a meaningful way, and thus, on this level, Burke’s theories on representative government are rather impractical. While it would be incredibly ideal to have representatives in government who know exactly what their people need and serve that, rather than what they want, this is not how Burke’s system of government functions in a large reality such as the United States government. Such a system often leads to not only unhappy people, but an unhappy, unstable, and ineffective country as a whole.
          Â
The national interest is an inseparable part of representative democracy, and remains at the very heart of Burke’s philosophy regarding governmental responsibility. Though the government truly exists to serve the national interest, the question remains whether the national interest exists, or if it is just an ideal concept intended to illustrate the way government is supposed to work, rather than how it does work. Burke claims that the national interest takes precedence over all kinds of local interests and public opinion. However, it is debatable whether any representative is truly aware of the national interest in general. The national interest is the policies and laws that the country requires to function effectively and to please its people. By this definition however, it stands to reason that anyone who has knowledge of the national interest possesses incredible foresight regarding the state of the country. Edmund Burke distinguishes between the national interest and the opinion of the people as two separate entities. Interestingly enough, if one defines the national interest as the majority opinion of the nation, then the two concepts of national interest and public opinion become virtually the same in nature. If one holds the opinion that national interest is defined by the people, then Burke’s argument promptly falls to pieces. One cannot separate national interest from personal opinions if they are defined by one another and thus, ignoring, or rather selectively absorbing public opinion actually deprives legislatures of the pertinent information they need regarding the needs of their country. Through this analysis, one can see that Burke’s argument is rather idealistic in nature, and requires the representatives to rely on a higher power in order to glean an effective strategy for government. Where does this wisdom truly come from? If there is no higher power to guide the representatives, are they not simply avoiding the obvious truth that they are there to serve the people, and as a result must listen to them? As Burke bases his argument on this idealistic notion of a higher power, his argument falls apart at the definition of national interest.
   Â
When one applies Edmund Burke’s political and governmental theory to the modern United States government, one is undoubtedly going to find a significant different between the two political philosophies. Though Burke argued that representative government that pandered to its constituents is destructive and ineffective, the United States government does exactly this. Representatives of the United States government often are forced to pander to their constituents in order to get reelected. Through the institution of term limits, the United States has allowed representatives to be checked by their constituents. This virtually limits the freedom of decision that a legislature would have if it did not have to worry about its job depending on the opinion of the people it represented. Unfortunately, in the United States, the people define the government as good when it serves them directly. This requires the government to serve the interests of a variety of political philosophies and social ideologies. In doing so, the government not only grossly overextends itself, but it often divides over politically sensitive issues such as taxes. The people of the United States do not care whether the government is serving the national interest, in the short term or the long term. The government has become an entirely results driven institution. If the people do not approve of the decisions of a representative, he or she will lose their job. Through this system, the government has become incredibly ineffective, as Burke predicted that it would.  The system in action prevents representatives from serving the country first, and rather forces them to pander to the minor whims and desires of those who elected them. In doing so, this has greatly reduced the capacity for action in the Federal government, with the debate over petty social issues such as abortion ruling the legislative capabilities of Congress. With a two party system, the government is divided between two entirely different sets of interests and goals intended to please the very people that put them in office. This system has done exactly what Burke predicted that it would, and in doing so, vindicates Burke to some extent in his political philosophy.Â
Regardless of the methods involved, representative government is intended to serve the people, whether through the pursuit of the national interest or through the placation of a representative’s constituents.  As long as man has walked the earth, he has searched for a way to modify his surroundings in order to better live. This is precisely the purpose of representative government. However, as Edmund Burke describes in his Speech to the Electors of Bristol, representative government should ideally not be placed entirely subject to the fickle and often selfish whims of the general population. These ideas greatly influenced the political philosophies of the founding fathers as they created a new government and a new country, the United States of America. Unfortunately, though Burke is correct in theory, the practice of his political ideology often leads to a total alienation of the people from the governmental process that control them, resulting in an unhappy populace. Additionally, if one considers the national interest to be defined by the majority of opinion in a country, then Burke’s argument promptly falls apart due to the combination of the two distinctions he makes, the national interest and the opinions of the constituents. When applied to the modern governmental system of the United States, one can barely see remnants of Burke’s political ideology in Congress. Representatives are often slaves and workhorses of the people they represent, living in constant fear that they may lose their job if they fail to produce what their base considers progress. This governmental system prevents legislatures from acting freely in their decisions, and somewhat vindicates Burke’s political theories. However, when examined from a realistic perspective, one must understand that people must play an active role in their government, not to prevent their representatives from acting free, but to ensure that those representing them are connected with a relevant common good for all.
Retrieved from “http://www.articlesbase.com/education-articles/edmund-burke-his-views-on-representative-government-3137294.html”
(ArticlesBase SC #3137294)
Nicolas DAlleva -
About the Author:
This article has been provided by Specialty Answering Service. Specialty is available as an Minnesota answering service and Colorado answering service provider. We answer for each client 24 hours a day and follow their instructions to handle each inbound or outbound communication perfectly.
]]>
Rate this Article
vote(s)
0 vote(s)
Feedback
RSS
Print
Email
Re-Publish
Article Tags:
national interest, representative government, united states
Latest Education Articles
More from Nicolas DAlleva
How to Run for Office – Governing Philosophy
Expert Ron Faucheux shares his tips and techniques on how to start a political career – Why is it important to understand my governing philosophy, the values I represent and the public image I want to convey? (01:48)
How to Use Insurance Commission
Trouble with your carrier? Get the government on your side when your carrier isn’t. (01:46)
C-SPAN Founder and CEO Brian Lamb Interview
In 2003 Reason named C-SPAN Founder and CEO Brian Lamb one of our 35 Heroes of Freedom for “turning a surveillance camera on the den of iniquity known as the U.S. House of Representatives.†Lamb sat down with Reason.tv editor Nick Gillespie for a wide-ranging and distinctively non-stoned faced discussion about the network and his views on politics. (37:25)
The Secretive Nature of the American Government
Bill Richardson, Governor of New Mexico (D), talks about how the American government is too secretive. (02:46)
Government’s Role in Alleviating Poverty
Muhammad Yunus, managing director of Grameen Bank, talks about the important role of the government in alleviating poverty. (02:34)
The Bald Eagle, National Symbol of the United States of America
For many years I taught my fifth grade students about the symbols of the United States of America. Over the years I have grown to love our national symbol, the American Bald Eagle. Many students are shocked to learn that our national symbol is not the flag, but the Bald Eagle.
By:
caroline mackayl
Education>
K-12 Educationl
Aug 07, 2007
lViews: 876
Mexican Nationals fleeing into the United States
Shopkeepers along the U.S. Mexican border recite the list of “protection” fees they pay to the MDC’s to just stay in business: 100 pesos a month for a stall in a street market, 30,000 pesos for an auto dealership or construction-supply firm.
First offense for nonpayment: a severe beating. Those who keep ignoring the fees – or try to charge their own – may pay with their lives
By:
michael Websterl
News and Societyl
Sep 15, 2009
How To Fly The United State Flag:
Show our patriotism: The American Flag is flying everwhere. The highly respected American Flag has been a symbol of the United States of America for over 200 years. American Flags fly from poles, windows, automobiles, trucks, in parades, at graveyards and just about anywhere.
By:
Tanyal
Educationl
Feb 24, 2009
lViews: 358
The Ex-presidents of the United States of America – Richard Nixon
The Ex-Presidents of the United States of America – Richard Nixon
By:
Russell Shorttl
News and Society>
Politicsl
Jan 29, 2009
lViews: 186
Green Card Lottery USAFIS United States Immigration Part Two Hundred Twenty Five
The yearly green card lottery or USAFIS Diversity Visa or DV lottery program is an opportunity for immigrants to gain permanent legal resident status in the USA. This program runs every year and makes available 50,000 green cards to applicants indiscriminately selected in a lottery process branded as the Green Card Lottery. A Green Card is a permanent residence visa and awards a person the legal right to live, work and study permanently in the United States of America
By:
Clyde Thorburnl
Travel>
Destinationsl
Jun 10, 2010
How many “illegal” (the term for one side of the debate) or “undocumented” (the preferred term by the other side) immigrants are there in America? The Department of Homeland Security indicated about 10.8 million in 2009. So for the purpose of this proposed contract and article, we are going to say, “the 11 Million Immigrants” (11M), and this essential issue should be resolved with the American Citizens (AC) and not with any Democrat or Republican party..
By:
Zoilo Nietol
News and Society>
Politicsl
May 10, 2010
Green Card Lottery USAFIS United States Immigration Part Three Hundred Eighteen
The yearly green card lottery or USAFIS Diversity Visa or DV lottery program is an opportunity for immigrants to gain permanent legal resident status in the USA. This program runs every year and makes available 50,000 green cards to applicants indiscriminately selected in a lottery process branded as the Green Card Lottery. A Green Card is a permanent residence visa and awards a person the legal right to live, work and study permanently in the United States of America.
By:
Clyde Thorburnl
Law>
Immigrationl
Oct 21, 2010
Cloud Formations and What They Mean
One of the utility of understanding cloud formation is to enable weather prediction.
By:
Greg Correll
Educationl
Nov 07, 2010
Improving Academics by Not Falling Behind
The focus of this article is help with what you can do to prevent from falling behind
By:
Greg Correll
Educationl
Nov 07, 2010
Tips On How To Identify Bad Classroom Management
The Best Way To Recognize Bad Classroom Management Bad classroom management is usually a period that each instructor attempts to stop. This merely indicates that you are ineffective being a teacher. In one way or another, teachers frequently encounter incompetence problems. All things considered, class supervision is often a proficiency that simply cannot be trained and digested in one day. It is watered by simply numerous years of experience. Even experienced instructors still e…
By:
Daryl Dodsonl
Educationl
Nov 07, 2010
Top 10 Undergraduate Business Schools
In identifying the programs employed at the top Undergraduate Business Schools, BusinessWeek employs a methodology comprised of nine various measures of student satisfaction, academic quality and post-graduate outcomes.
By:
Gregory Bkerl
Educationl
Nov 06, 2010
Education Now for Success Later
It still remains true that learning and gaining knowledge are important to high achievement. Unfortunately many people don’t have access to quality education opportunities.
By:
Marlon Jacksonl
Educationl
Nov 06, 2010
The job market and economy are sharply down, but the number of people going to school is strong. It’s especially important that mothers have the tools to be able to care for their families.
By:
Marlon Jacksonl
Educationl
Nov 06, 2010
Scholarships For Women – Empowering the Female Mind
Around more than forty years ago, women are considered as a marginalized sector of society because of their inability to handle work and the continuing stereotype that men are more productive than the opposite sex. Usually, the ladies are always left at home to do household work while their counterparts go to their respective workplace.
By:
Michale Anderson-Smithl
Educationl
Nov 06, 2010
Moms: Get the Scholarship Then Get the Education
The US economy continues to struggle, and that unfortunately leaves many people with uncertain futures. Many people have lost jobs, and finding new employment has been difficult.
By:
Marlon Jacksonl
Educationl
Nov 06, 2010
Looking to Start Your Own Business
Starting your own business requires a plan and perserverence. After the initial hardships, the payoffs of starting your own business are worth any initial difficulties.
By:
Nicolas DAlleval
Business>
Outsourcingl
Nov 03, 2010
Geocaching involves the use of a GPS navigational system to find hidden objects around the globe. It is referred to as a form of recreational treasure hunting
By:
Nicolas DAlleval
Businessl
Nov 03, 2010
Amateur Radio Information & Resources
Amateur Radio, also known as ham radio, is a largely a communication hobby where operators can receive transmissions from great distances
By:
Nicolas DAlleval
Business>
Outsourcingl
Nov 03, 2010
Call Centers Benefit Businesses
Call centers benefit businesses by offering 24 hour secretarial and sales support for a lower price than hiring your own internal staff.
By:
Nicolas DAlleval
Business>
Outsourcingl
Nov 03, 2010
Offshore call centers are often a more affordable option than United States based call center service companies.
By:
Nicolas DAlleval
Business>
Outsourcingl
Nov 03, 2010
Starting your own business? Here are a few helpful tips to get you started on the right path.
By:
Nicolas DAlleval
Business>
Outsourcingl
Nov 03, 2010
Telephone museums showcase early telephones as well as the history of the telephone. They are a nostalgic look at the evolution of telephones
By:
Nicolas DAlleval
Business>
Outsourcingl
Nov 03, 2010
A Brief History of Data Communications
Data communications have evolved from the days of telegraph communication to its current state of mobile communications and high speed data transfers.
By:
Nicolas DAlleval
Business>
Outsourcingl
Nov 03, 2010
Add new Comment
Your Name: *
Your Email:
Comment Body: *
Â
Verification code:*
* Required fields
Submit
Your Articles Here
It’s Free and easy
Sign Up Today
Author Navigation
My Home
Publish Article
View/Edit Articles
View/Edit Q&A
Edit your Account
Manage Authors
Statistics Page
Personal RSS Builder
My Home
Edit your Account
Update Profile
View/Edit Q&A
Publish Article
Author Box
Nicolas DAlleva has 192 articles online
Articles Categories
All Categories
Advertising
Arts & Entertainment
Automotive
Beauty
Business
Careers
Computers
Education
Finance
Food and Beverage
Health
Hobbies
Home and Family
Home Improvement
Internet
Judaism
Law
Marketing
News and Society
Relationships
Self Improvement
Shopping
Spirituality
Sports and Fitness
Technology
Travel
Writing
ADHD
Childhood Education
College and University
History
Homeschooling
International Studies
K-12 Education
Languages
Learning Disabilities
Online Education
Science
Tutoring
]]>
Need Help?
Contact Us
FAQ
Submit Articles
Editorial Guidelines
Blog
Site Links
Recent Articles
Top Authors
Top Articles
Find Articles
Site Map
Webmasters
RSS Builder
RSS
Link to Us
Business Info
Advertising
Use of this web site constitutes acceptance of the Terms Of Use and Privacy Policy | User published content is licensed under a Creative Commons License.
Copyright © 2005-2010 Free Articles by ArticlesBase.com, All rights reserved.
This article has been provided by Specialty Answering Service. Specialty is available as an Minnesota answering service and Colorado answering service provider. We answer for each client 24 hours a day and follow their instructions to handle each inbound or outbound communication perfectly.
This is an excerpt from “Overview of America” produced by The John Birch Society. It is narrated by John? McManus. The true American form of government was meant to be a constitutional republic not a democracy, or anything else. Democracy means mob rule. 51% of the people rule the other 49%.
Video Rating: 4 / 5
Find More Government Articles
